分享两篇SCI发表的经历coverletterresponseletter.docx
《分享两篇SCI发表的经历coverletterresponseletter.docx》由会员分享,可在线阅读,更多相关《分享两篇SCI发表的经历coverletterresponseletter.docx(7页珍藏版)》请在冰豆网上搜索。
分享两篇SCI发表的经历coverletterresponseletter
分享两篇SCI发表的经历
三年前对于我来说SCI就是天书一样,在我踏进博士的门槛后我以为自己进入了地狱,也纠结也彷徨,整天刷虫友们对于博士、SCI的帖子,我选择了虫友们鼓励的那一部分来激励自己继续前行。
我告诉自己坚持就是胜利,当然那是积极的坚持。
在好几月之前就有这个想法,今天早上收到第二篇的接收通知后,我便想今天一定要在小木虫上那些给予我帮助的虫友们。
话不多说,我把自己这两篇投稿的经历与大家共享,希望能给大家带来一点点用处。
第一篇发表在FitoterapiaCoverletterDearEditorVerotta:
Wewouldliketosubmitthemanuscriptentitled"××××××题目"by××××××所有作者whichwewishtobeconsideredforpublicationinJournalofFitoterapia.Allauthorshavereadandapprovedthisversionofthearticle,andduecarehasbeentakentoensuretheintegrityofthework.Neithertheentirepapernoranypartofitscontenthasbeenpublishedorhasbeenacceptedelsewhere.Itisnotbeingsubmittedtoanyotherjournal. Webelievethepapermaybeofparticularinteresttothereadersofyourjournalasitisthefirsttimeof××××××研究的精华所在ThankyouverymuchforyourreconsideringourrevisedmanuscriptforpotentialpublicationinFitoterapia.Wearelookingforwardtohearingfromyousoon.CorrespondenceshouldbeaddressedtoJinhuiYuatthefollowingaddress,phoneandfaxnumber,andemailaddress.地址、学院、学校名称Phone:
+86××××××Faxnumber:
+86571××××××Emailaddress:
××××××163.Bestwishesforyouandyourfamily!
Sincerelyyours,×××所有作者ResponsetoreviewersDearEditor:
ThankyouverymuchforyourletterandthementsfromtherefereesaboutourpapersubmittedtoJournalofFitoterapia(FITOTE-D-11-01071).Themanuscriptentitled"××××××"by××××××所有作者havebeenrevisedaccordingtothereviewers’ments,andwewishittobereconsideredforpublicationinJournalofFitoterapia.Alistofchangesandresponsestoreviewersareasfollows.ListofActionsLOA1:
Thekeywordswerechangedinpage?
.LOA2:
Thenameandlocationofthelocalbiochemistrypanyhavebeenaddedinsection2.1(page3).LOA3:
Aparagraphhasbeenaddedinsection3.1(page5)tofurtherexplainthedeterminationofthecisandtransconfigurationofdoublebondsinpolyprenols.LOA4:
ThelanguagewasimprovedbyEnglishlanguageeditingofElsevierwebshop.ToReviewer1#,Thankyouverymuchforpointingouttheproblemsinourmanuscript.Wehavereviseditaccordingtoyourremendations.Wewouldliketoknowiftherearestillsomewhereneedtobeamended.
(1)Keywords:
generaltermsshouldbeavoided;Iwouldchangesomeofthekeywords(homologues,identification,quantification)Thekeywordshavebeenchangedasfollows:
××××××修改后关键词
(2)Inparagraph2.1the"localbiochemistrypany"shouldbeidentifiedbynameandlocation.Thenameandlocationofthelocalbiochemistrypanyhavebeenaddedinsection2.1(page3).NaOH,Pyrogallol,anhydrousNa2SO4werepurchasedfromHangzhouChangqingHuagongCO.,LTD.(3)Howthecisandtransconfigurationofdoublebondsin××××××weredetermined?
Authorsshouldsaysomethingabout.Thefollowingparagraphhasbeenaddedinsection3.1(page5)tofurtherexplainthedeterminationofthecisandtransconfigurationofdoublebondsin××××××.(4)Languageshouldbecheckedforclarityandcorrectness.ThelanguagewasimprovedbyEnglishlanguageeditingofElsevierwebshop.ToReviewer2#,ThankyouverymuchforyourremendationonourpaperandwehaveimprovedbyEnglishlanguageeditingofElsevierwebshop. Allinall,thankyouverymuchforyourreconsideringourrevisedmanuscriptforpotentialpublicationinFitoterapia.I'mlookingforwardtohearingfromyousoon.Correspondenceshouldbeaddressedto****第一作者或通讯作者 atthefollowingaddress,phoneandfaxnumber,andemailaddress.地址Phone:
+86571××××××Faxnumber:
+××××××Emailaddress:
××××××163.Bestwishesforyouandyourfamily!
Sincerelyyours,××××××所有作者总的来说,第一篇文章没有费很大劲。
投稿后二个月左右便有消息,小修后提交,第二天便接收了!
那是因为这篇文章是历经磨难后的,之前投了Separation of science和JPBA,其中第一个期刊当天就给我回复了,那肯定是悲剧的!
编辑所谓的与该期刊不符,但我认为主要是因为文章写的太垃圾,那是我第一次写SCI而且是没有任何人指点的情况下,可想而知会有多烂。
随后这篇文章放了将近一年,填补了写数据,又投了第二个期刊,编辑委婉的拒了但给我修改重投的机会。
我按照审稿人的意见和建议修改了几个月后重投(补数据,重新整结构框架,仅次于重写),结果悲剧了。
而且不是因为修改的问题,而是说我的文章档次太低,不足以在JPBA上发表,我当时晕倒怎么不早说,害我这么长时间的重修。
不过现在想想若不是重修在下次的投稿中又怎能如此顺利呢?
所以说所有的努力都不是白费的!
第二篇投了JournalofEthnopharmacology,相比第一篇这个稍有磨难。
也是差不多两个月的样子收到修改意见,修改后提交一直不见动静,等两个月左右的时候我有点hold不住了,编发了一封催稿信,之前看论坛里说忌讳催稿,但也看期刊吧,JournalofEthnopharmacology的编辑第二天便给了修改建议(还是要修改),原因是第一次修改是一个审稿人的,由于另外一个审稿人一直没给才拖到第二次。
也没办法,只能再改!
这次相对比较快点,每到一个月便通知接收了。
JournalofEthnopharmacology与别的期刊不同,有一份Author_checklist。
不算重要但还是给大家附上附件吧(黏贴好像乱掉了),我之前也是请教的虫友。
需要提醒的是初次提交和修改后要注意最后一项打勾。
Deareditor,Wewouldliketosubmitthemanuscriptentitled"××××××"by××××××whichwewishtobeconsideredforpublicationinJournalofEthnopharmacology.Allauthorshavereadandapprovedthisversionofthearticle,andduecarehasbeentakentoensuretheintegrityofthework.Neithertheentirepapernoranypartofitscontenthasbeenpublishedorhasbeenacceptedelsewhere.Itisnotbeingsubmittedtoanyotherjournal. Webelievethepapermaybeofparticularinteresttothereadersofyourjournalasitisthefirsttimeofinvestigating××××××CorrespondenceshouldbeaddressedtoJinhuiYuatthefollowingaddress,phoneandfaxnumber,andemailaddress.地址Phone:
+86××××××Faxnumber:
+86571××××××Emailaddress:
××××××163.Thankyouverymuchforyourconsideringourmanuscriptforpotentialpublication.I'mlookingforwardtohearingfromyousoon.Bestwishesforyouandyourfamily!
Sincerelyyours,××××××小异 单独提交revision notes第一次修改Alistofchangesandresponsestoreviewersareasfollows.ListofActionsLOA1:
Thereferenceontheselectionofdoseshasbeenadaptedinsection2.2(page5).LOA2:
ThedetailsofHPLCdataweresupplementedinsection2.1(page4).LOA3:
Figure3,figure4andfigure5havebeenredrawn. Repliestotheremarksofthereviewer1:
Theauthorsappreciatevaluablesuggestionsandmentsfromtheanonymousreviewers.Wehaverevisedourmanuscriptaccordingly.Hopeitissatisfactorynow.
(1)Howthedoseshavebeenselected?
Ifthedoseshavebeenadaptedfromapreviouspublicationpleasecitethepaper. Thedoseswereselectedaccordingtopreviousstudiesof××××××。
Wehaveadaptedthepaperinourrevisedmanuscript.
(2)ItwouldbemoreinterestingiftheauthorscouldshowthedetailsofHPLCdatainthismanuscript.Whichfractionhasbeenusedtoperformexperiments?
WehaveprovidedtheHPLCchromatogramof××××××usedintheanimalexperiment.Thefractionofthepurifiedextractmostlyconsistedof××××××,whichaccountingfor0.22%,1.06%,5.65%,13.96%,10.82%,6.70%,14.47%,22.81%,16.64%,6.13%,1.52%,respectively.Thepurityofthe××××××wasassessedusingHPLC,amountingto>85%. (3)Fig3and5shouldberedone.Photosmaytakebyusinglittlemorehigherobjectiveslike32Xor40Xtoshowthepictureclearly.Scalebarsshouldbementionedinsidethefigure(inrightcorner).Weredrewthebothfigures.Scalebarshavebeenmentionedinsidethefigure3,figure4andfigure5.Themagnificationof200×wasadoptedforfigure3andfigure5,referringtomanypreviousstudies(Guietal.,2006;Hsiehetal.,2011;Jungetal.,2012;Xiaoetal.,2012).Thereviewer'sconcernabouttheinsufficientlyclearfiguresmightresultfromthelowresolutionofthepictureinourpreviousversion.Correspondingpictureswithimprovedresolutionwereprovided,whichappearmuchclearer.Wecanalsoprovideoriginalfiguresifitisnecessary.References:
Gui,S.Y.,Wei,W.,Wang,H.,Wu,L.,Sun,W.Y.,Chen,W.B.andWu,C.Y.,2006.Effectsandmechanismsofcrudeastragalosidesfractiononliverfibrosisinrats.JournalofEthnopharmacology103:
154-159.Hsieh,W.T.,Liu,Y.T.andLin,W.C.,2011.Anti-inflammatorypropertiesofAjugabracteosainvivoandinvitrostudyandtheireffectsonmousemodelofliverfibrosis.JournalofEthnopharmacology135:
116-125.Jung,H.W.,Jung,J.K.,Son,K.H.,Lee,D.H.,Kang,T.M.,Kim,Y.S.andPark,Y.K.,2012.InhibitoryeffectsoftherootextractofDipsacusasperoidesC.Y.Chengetalt.m.aioncollagen-inducedarthritisinmice.JournalofEthnopharmacology139:
98-103.Xiao,J.,Liong,E.C.,Ching,Y.P.,Chang,R.C.,So,K.F.,Fung,M.L.andTipoe,G.L.,2012.Lyciumbarbarumpolysaccharidesprotectmiceliverfromcarbontetrachloride-inducedoxidativestressandnecroinflammation.JournalofEthnopharmacology139:
462-470.Yu,J.,Wang,Y.,Qian,H.,Zhao,Y.,Liu,B.andFu,C.PolyprenolsfromtheneedlesofTaxuschinensisvar.mairei.Fitoterapia,inrevison.第二次修改Alistofchangesandresponsestoreviewersareasfollows.ListofActionsLOA1:
ThedescriptionoftheeffectofTPs(protectiveratherthantherapeutic)inthearticlewascorrectedtoavoidmisunderstanding. Introduction,thelastsentence(paragraph3).Section3.1,“RatstreatedwithTPs”waschangedas“RatstreatedwithbothTPsandCCl4”(line3)Section3.5,“intheliversofchronicCCl4treatedrats”wasdeletedbyadding“InthetreatmentwithTPs+CCl4”attheheadofthesentence.(line7)Discussion,thefirstandthelastsentence(paragraph1).Discussion,“thetreatmentwithTPs”waschangedas“thetreatmentwithTPs+CCl4”(paragraph2,line9)Discussion,thelastsentence(paragraph4)Discussion,thelastsentence(paragraph5)Discussion,thefirstsentence(paragraph7)LOA2:
Thefiguresandtablesareexplainedinorderinthemaintext. Section3.1,Fig.3A(line6)wasadded.Section3.3,Fig.4A(line2),Fig.4B-C(line3)andFig.4B(line9)andFig.4A-B(line10)weredeleted.Section3.4,Fig.5A,F(line3),Fig.5C-E,F(line5)wereadded. LOA3:
Figure2wassupplementedwiththestandardchromatogramandconcreteinformationaboutthepeaksunderthefigure. LOA4:
Thepetroleumwascorrectedintopetroleumether.LOA5:
Thediscussionsectionwasmodified.Repliestotheremarksofthereviewer2:
Theauthorsappreciatevaluablesuggestionsandmentsfromtheanonymousreviewers.Wehaverevisedourmanuscriptaccordingly.1.Fig6showsthat××××××onRNAexpressionisnotdosedependent,rathe