从概念隐喻角度分析BBC新闻和VOA新闻Word文档下载推荐.docx
《从概念隐喻角度分析BBC新闻和VOA新闻Word文档下载推荐.docx》由会员分享,可在线阅读,更多相关《从概念隐喻角度分析BBC新闻和VOA新闻Word文档下载推荐.docx(9页珍藏版)》请在冰豆网上搜索。
从概念隐喻角度分析BBC新闻和VOA新闻WangHeng(TianjinUniversityRenaiCollege,Tianjin,301636)[Abstract]Newshasbecomeanimportantwayofgettinginformationfromhomeandabroad,andknowingtheconceptualmetaphorinnewscouldhelppeopleunderstanditbetter.ThepaperisananalysisofBBCNewsandVOANewsfromtheperspectiveofconceptualmetaphor.AnditaimsatfindingoutthesimilaritiesanddifferencesbetweenBBCNewsandVOANews,therefore,itsummariestheconceptualmetaphorthatareutilizedinBBCNewsandVOANewsanddrawstheconclusion,sothepapercouldfinallyhelppeopleunderstandBBCNewsandVOANewsbetter.[Keywords]conceptualmetaphor,BBCNews,VOANews[中图分类号]H313[文献标识码]A[文章编号]1672-8610(2016)05-0045-06[作者简介]王亨,男,内蒙古人,天津大学仁爱学院助理实验师,硕士研究生。
I.IntroductionTheconceptualmetaphor,andadetailedexaminationoftheunderlyingprocesses,wasfirstextensivelyexploredbyGeorgeLakoffandMarkJohnsonintheirworkMetaphorsWeLiveBy.Therearethreekindsofconceptualmetaphor,ie,theontologicalmetaphor,whichisunderstandingourexperiencesintermsofobjectsandsubstancessothatitcouldallowustopickoutpartsofourexperienceandtreatthemasdiscreteentitiesorsubstancesofauniformkind(Lakoff,Johnson,1980,26);
theorientationalmetaphorisakindofmetaphorthatmostofthemhavetodowithspatialorientation:
up-down,in-out,front-back,on-off,deep-shallow,central-peripheral(Lakoff,Johnson,1980,15);
andstructuralmetaphorisaboutcaseswhereoneconceptismetaphoricallystructuredintermsofanother.ThisresearchconcernstheconceptualmetaphorsinBBCNewsandVOANews,andtherearesomeconceptualmetaphorsinBBCNewsandVOANewsarenoteasytobeunderstoodbecausecultural,experientialandotherfactors,andsometimeswecouldnotfindsomesocalled“deadmetaphor”whichweusecommonlyinourcommunicationanddonotfeeltheyaremetaphors.Ⅱ.AnalysisofBBCNewsandVOANewsfromthePerspectiveofConceptualMetaphor2.1ThepoliticaldiscourseanalysisThematerialsunderthisdiscoursearefromofficialwebsitesofBBCandVOA,whichareaboutPutin’swiningofRussianelection.1.WarmetaphorMappingTable1ThemappingofwarmetaphorinpoliticaldiscourseXia(2011)saysthatwarmetaphorisbasedonsomesimilaritiesbetweeneconomic,politicalfieldsandwar,andtherearesomebasicelementsintheentityofwar,suchasbattlefield,rivals,andfightingpurpose.Whentheseelementsaremappedontoeconomicandpoliticalfields,theywouldhelppeopleunderstandtheabstracteconomicandpolitical“war”.Thefollowingsaresomespecificexamples:
BBC:
1.MrPutintoldsupportersatarallyincentralMoscowtheyhadwoninanopenandhonestbattle.2.“Weprovedthatno-onecanforceanythingonus.”3.Apparentlymovedtotears,heroaredintriumphatthecrowdanddescribedtheelectionasabattleforsurvivalagainstadangerousfoewhohadnowbeenvanquished.VOA:
4.Putinwonapresidentialelectionlaterthatyearandagainin20045.PutinWinsABattle,ButIsHeLosingtheWar?
6.…duringhiscampaignhemadepromisesoflavishspendingtowinsupportthattheRussianeconomysimplycan’tsustain.2.HumanmetaphorMappingTable2ThemappingofhumanmetaphorfromwarmetaphorinpoliticaldiscourseInfact,whenittalksaboutsomeelementsofwarinwarmetaphor,suchasbattlefield,resultofwar,itappliestheontologicalmetaphor—humanmetaphortodescribethem.Therefore,inwarmetaphoritcontainshumanmetaphorinpoliticaldiscourse.Thefollowingsaresomespecificexamples:
1.Exitpollsandpreliminaryresultsgavehimabout60%ofthevote.2.Butitcouldeatawayathisauthorityif,asinDecember,itpropelsoutragedcitizensontothestreetsagaintoprotestinlargenumbersatanunfairsystem.3.Russiamaynotbefacingrevolution.VOA:
4.PreliminaryresultsgivePutin64percentofthevoteandhisclosestrival,CommunistPartychiefGennadyZyuganov,17percent.Threeothercandidateswonlessthan10percent.5.Hemustgovernadeeplyfracturedcountryinwhichsignificantnumbersofitsfledglingmiddleclassseehisreturntopowerasillegitimate—andhavetakentothestreetstomaketheircase.ItwasalsodiscoveredthatinBBCNewstheaspectsrivalandbattlefieldappearmorethaninVOANews,whileVOANewsstressesnoone.Thefollowingsaresomespecificexamples:
1.MeanwhiletensofthousandsofsupportersofMrPutingatheredwithRussianflagsandbannersoutsidetheKremlinforaconcerttocelebratehisvictory.2.“Weprovedthatno-onecanforceanythingonus.”VOA:
3.HetearfullygreetedtensofthousandsofsupportersoutsidetheKremlinSunday,thankingthemforstoppingthecountryfrom,inhiswords,“fallingintothehandsofenemiestryingtousurppower.”Besidesthisdifference,BBCNewsandVOANewshasanotherdifferencewhicharedifferenttrendsofusingwords.Herearesomeexamples:
1.Thereistightsecurityinthecity,with6,000extrapolicebroughtinfromoutside2.Theelectionwasheldagainstabackdropofpopulardiscontent,sparkedbyallegationsofwidespreadfraudduringDecember’sparliamentaryelectionsinfavourofMrPutin’sUnitedRussiaparty.3.RepeatedlyMrPutinhaswarnedthatsomeactivists,fuelledbysupportfromabroad,mightbetryingtofuelpublicdisorderwiththeaimofsowingtheseedsofchaosandbringingdownthegovernment.4.HethoughttheycouldhaveafruitfuldialogueaboutMrProkhorov’splantosetupanewpoliticalparty.5.ButtheharshpopulistlanguagethatpepperedMrPutin’sspeechesduringtheelectioncampaigndoleaveopenanoppositepossibility.SourcedomainTargetdomain1ClothesSecurity2FireDiscontent3Car/plantingDisorder/chaos4HarvestDialogue5PepperLanguageVOA:
1.EuropeanobserverssayRussia’spresidentialelectionwasclearlyskewedtofavorPrimeMinisterVladimirPutin,whowonbyalandslide2.Incontrasttohisrisetopoweroveradecadeagowhenhewashailedasatough-mindedsaviorwhowouldbringstabilitytoRussiaafterthechaosofthe1990s.3.He’salsolostthewarthathecan’tconvincetheprotestersthatRussiaisontracktowardmodernizationandapluralisticpoliticalsystem.“SourcedomainTargetdomain1StickElection2RainPeople3TrainCountry2.2TheMilitaryDiscourseAnalysisThematerialsinthisdiscoursearefromofficialwebsitesofBBCandVOA,whichareaboutNorthKorealaunchingofarocket.
1.WarmetaphorMappingTable3ThemappingofwarmetaphorinmilitarydiscourseInmilitarydiscourse,itislikeinpoliticaldiscourse.Thefollowingsaresomespecificexamples:
1.RussiasaidonTuesdaysaidthatPyongyang’splansshowed“disregard”fortheresolutions.2.“Wecallonpartiesconcernedtostaycalm,exerciserestraintandavoidescalationoftensionsontheKoreanpeninsula,”foreignministryspokesmanLiuWeiminsaidatapressbriefingonTuesday.3.APentagonspokesmansaidUSDefenceSecretaryLeonPanettahadspokentohisSouthKoreancounterpartonthephonelateMonday.Bothleaderswouldregardthelaunch“asaseriousprovocation”,thespokesmansaid.VOA:
4.Aninitialconclusion:
NorthKoreaseemstohavemadesignificantprogresssinceitsfailedattempt,threeyearsago,toconductathree-stagelaunchandputasatelliteintoorbit.5.Kaneda,inanNHKinterview,notedanapparentclusteroffourrocketengineshousedinthefirststage.Hedescribedthatasworrisomebecausefournozzlesinthefirststageleavenodoubtthatthisrocketcouldbeutilizedasalong-rangeballisticmissile,capableofnotonlyreachingJapan,butalsotheU.S.mainland.6.ThedefenseministryspokesmansaysthatbecauseSouthKoreanofficialsdidnotvisitthere,theyarenotinapositiontocommentonthetechnicalcapabilitiesoftheNorthKoreanrocket.2.HumanmetaphorMappingTable4ThemappingofhumanmetaphorfromwarmetaphorinmilitarydiscourseInthemilitarydiscourse,COUNTRYISAPERSONisthehumanmetaphorthatappearsmosttimes.Thefollowingsaresomeexamples.BBC:
1.NorthKoreaispoisedtocompletepreparationsforitsrocketlaunchscheduledforlaterthisweek,anofficialsaidinPyongyang2.China,oneofNorthKorea’sclosestallies,urgedallpartiestoremaincalm.3.JapanandSouthKoreahavewarnedtheywillshoottherocketdownifitthreatenstheirterritory.VOA:
4.NorthKoreasaysthethirdstageistocarryanearthobservationsatelliteintoanorth-southorbit.5.BothSouthKoreaandJapanarevowingtoattempttoshootdowntheNorthKoreanrocketifitsveersoffcourseandovertheirterritories.6.NorthKoreahasnotifiedrelevantinternationalaviationandmaritimeauthoritiesthatitwillconductthelaunchbetweenThursdaymorningandnextMonday.Inmilitarydiscourse,thedifferencesbetweenBBCNewsandVOANewsofapplyingconceptualmetaphorcouldbeseenfromtwoways,thefirstoneistheyhavedifferentemphasisinwarmetaphor,thesecondoneisthatwhenconcretethingsareconcerned,theytendtousedifferentmetaphors,thefollowingsaresomeexamples:
1.Asthe100,000peoplefiledoutofthesquareourgroupofjournalistswashurriedawaybyourminders.2.PyongyanghadagreedinFebruarytoapartialfreezeinnuclearactivitiesandamissiletestmoratoriuminreturnforUSfoodaidSourcedomainTargetdomain1FilePeople2IceactivityVOA:
1.VideoimagesandphotographstakenduringamediaviewingofwhatNorthKoreaiscallingtheUnha-3rockethavegivendefenseanalystsandtheintelligencecommunityafreshopportunitytoassessthestateofPyongyang’sballisticmissiledevelopment.2.Butratheronthelev