专听力真题答案及讲座原文.docx
《专听力真题答案及讲座原文.docx》由会员分享,可在线阅读,更多相关《专听力真题答案及讲座原文.docx(6页珍藏版)》请在冰豆网上搜索。
专听力真题答案及讲座原文
ThedocumentwaspreparedonJanuary2,2021
专听力真题答案及讲座原文
SECTIONAMINI-LECTURE
ModelsforArguments
Threemodelsforarguments
thefirstmodelforarguingiscalled
(1)_________;
—argumentsaretreatedaswar
—thereismuchwinningandlosing
—itisa
(2)__________modelforarguing
thesecondmodelforarguingisargumentsasproofs:
—(3)warranted__________
—validinferencesandconclusions
—no(4)__________intheadversarialsense
thethirdmodelforarguingis(5)_________:
—theaudienceis(6)__________inthearguments
—argumentsmust(7)__________theaudience
Traitsoftheargumentaswar
verydominant:
itcanshape(8)_________
strongargumentsareneeded
negativeeffectsinclude:
—(9)_________areemphasized
—winningistheonlypurpose
—thistypeofargumentsprevent(10)_________
—theworstthingis(11)_________
implicationfromargumentsaswar:
(12)_________
—.,oneprovidingreasonsandtheotherraising(13)_________
—theotheroneisfinallypersuaded
Suggestionsonnewwaysto(14)_________ofarguments
thinkofnewkindsofarguments
changerolesinarguments
(15)_________
SECTIONBINTERVIEW
Now,listentothePartOneoftheinterview.Questions1to5arebasedonPartOneoftheinterview.
1.Whatisthetopicoftheinterview
A.Maggie’suniversitylife.
B.Hermom’slifeatHarvard.
C.Maggie’sviewonstudyingwithMom.
D.Maggie’sopiniononhermom’smajor.
2.Whichofthefollowingindicatesthattheyhavethesamestudyschedule
A.Theytakeexamsinthesameweeks.
B.Theyhavesimilarlecturenotes.
C.Theyapplyforthesameinternship.
D.Theyfollowthesamefashion.
3.Whatdothemotherandthedaughterhaveincommonasstudents
A.Havingroommates.
B.Practicingcourttrails.
C.Studyingtogether.
D.Takingnotesbyhand.
4.WhatisthebiggestadvantageofstudyingwithMom
A.Protection.
B.Imagination.
C.Excitement.
D.Encouragement.
5.WhatisthebiggestdisadvantageofstudyingwithMom
A.ThinkingofwaystocomfortMom.
B.OccasionalinterferencefromMom.
C.UltimatelycallswhenMaggieisbusy.
D.FrequentcheckonMaggie’sgrades.
Now,listentothePartTwooftheinterview.Questions6to10arebasedonPartTwooftheinterview.
6.Whyisparentandkidstudyingtogetheracommoncase
A.Becauseparentsneedtobereadyfornewjobs.
B.Becauseparentslovetoreturntocollege.
C.Becausekidsrequiretheirparentstodoso.
D.Becausekidsfindithardtoadapttocollegelife.
7.WhatwouldMaggie’smomliketobeaftercollege
A.Realestateagent.
B.Financier.
C.Lawyer.
D.Teacher.
8.HowdoesMaggie’smomfeelaboutsittinginclassafter30years
A.Delighted.
B.Excited.
C.Bored.
D.Frustrated.
9.WhatismostchallengingforMaggie’smom
A.Howtomakeacake.
B.Howtomakeomelets.
C.Toacceptwhatistaught.
D.Toplanafuturecareer.
10.HowdoesMaggiedescribetheprocessofthinkingoutone’scareerpath
A.Unsuccessful.
B.Gradual.
C.Frustrating.
D.Passionate.
Keys:
1.thedialecticalmodel
monandfixed
3.premises
4.opposition/arguing
5.argumentsasperformances/therhetoricalmodel
6.participatory/participating/theparticipant/takingpart
7.betailoredto/caterfor
8.howweargue/ouractualconduct
9.tactics/strategies
10.negotiationandcollaboration
11.there’snosolution/progress
12.learningwithlosing
13.questions/counter-considerations/counter-arguments/objections/argumentsinopposition
14.achievepositiveeffects
15.supportoneself/yourself
CADDB
ACDCB
Script:
Goodmorning,everyone.MynameisDavidandIamgoodatarguing.Sowelcometoourintroductorylectureonargumentation.WhydowewanttoargueWhydowetrytoconvinceotherpeopletobelievethingsthattheydon’twanttobelieveAndisthatevenanicethingtodoIsthatanicewaytotreatotherhumanbeing,tryandmakethemthinksomethingtheydon’twanttothinkWell,myanswerisgoingtomakereferencetothreemodelsforarguments.
(1)Thefirstmodel—let’scallthisthedialecticalmodel—isthatwethinkofargumentsaswar.Andyouknowwhatthat’slike.Thereisalotofscreamingandshoutingandwinningandlosing.
(2)Andthat’snotreallyaveryhelpfulmodelarguing,butit’saprettycommonandfixedone.Iguessyoumusthaveseenthattypeofarguingmanytimes—inthestreet,onthebusorinthesubway.
Let’smoveontothesecondmodel.Thesecondmodelforarguingregardsargumentsasproofs.Thinkofamathematician’sargument.Here’smyargument.DoesitworkIsitanygood(3)Arethepremises(前提)warrantedAretheinferences(推论))validDoestheconclusionfollowthepremises(4)Noopposition,noadversariality(对抗)—notnecessarilyanyarguingintheadversarialsense.
(5)Andthere’sathirdmodeltokeepinmindthatIthinkisgoingtobeveryhelpful,andthatisargumentsasperformances,argumentsasbeinginfrontofanaudience.Wecanthinkofapoliticiantryingtopresentaposition,tryingtoconvincetheaudienceofsomething.
Butthere’sanothertwist(转折)onthismodelthatIreallythinkisimportant;namely,thatwhenwearguebeforeanaudience,(6)sometimestheaudiencehasamoreparticipatoryroleintheargument;thatis,youpresentyouargumentsinfrontofanaudiencewhoarelikejuries(陪审团)thatmakeajudgmentanddecidethecase.(5)Let’scallthismodeltherhetoricalmodel,(7)whereyouhavetotailor(迎合)yourargumenttotheaudienceathand.
Ofthosethree,theargumentaswaristhedominantone.Itdominateshowwetalkaboutarguments,itdominateshowwethinkaboutarguments,andbecauseofthat,(8)itshapeshowweargue,ouractualrightontarget.Wewanttohaveourdefensesupandourstrategiesallinorder.Wewantkillerarguments.That’sthekindofargumentwewant.Itisthedominantwayofthinkingaboutarguments.WhenI’mtalkingaboutarguments,that’sprobablywhatyouthoughtof,theadversarialmodel.
Butthewarmetaphor,thewarparadigm(范例)ormodelforthinkingaboutarguments,has,Ithink,negativeeffectsonhowweargue.(9)First,itelevatestacticsoversubstance.Youcantakeaclassinlogicargumentation.Youlearnallaboutthestrategiesthatpeopleusetotryandwinargumentsandthatmakesarguingadversarial;it’spolarizing(分化的).Andtheonlyforeseeableoutcomesaretriumph—glorioustriumph—ordisgraceful(可耻的)defeat.Ithinkthoseareverydestructiveeffects,andworstofall,(10)itseemstopreventthingslikenegotiationandcollaboration(合作).Um,Ithinktheargument-as-warmetaphorinhibits(阻止)thoseotherkindsofresolutionstoargumentation.
(11)Andfinally—thisisreallytheworstthing—argumentsdon’tseemtogetusanywhere;they’redeadends(死胡同).Wedon’tanywhere.Oh,andonemorething.(12)Thatis,ifargumentiswar,thenthere’salsoanimplicit(绝对的)aspectofmeaning—learningwithlosing.
AndletmeexplainwhatImean.SupposeyouandIhaveanargument.Youbelieveaproposition(命题)andIdon’t.AndIsay,“Well,whydoyoubelievethat”Andyougivemeyourreasons.AndIobjectandsay,“Well,whatabout…”AndIhaveaquestion:
“Well,whatdoyoumeanHowdoesitapplyoverhere”Andyouanswermyquestion.Now,supposeattheendoftheday,I’veobjected,I’vequestioned,(13)I’veraisedallsortsofquestionsfromanoppositeperspectiveandineverycaseyou’verespondedtomysatisfaction.Andsoattheendoftheday,Isay,“YouknowwhatIguessyou’reright.”MaybefinallyIlostmyargument.Butisn’titalsoaprocessoflearningSoyouseeargumentsmayalsohavepositiveeffects.
(14)So,howcanwefindnewwaystoachievethosepositiveeffectsWeneedtothinkofnewkindsofarguments.HereIhavesomesuggestion.Ifwewanttothinkofnewkindsofargument,whatweneedtodoisthinkofnewkindsofarguers—peoplewhoargue.
Sotrythis:
Thinkofalltherolesthatpeopleplayinarguments.
(1)(5)There’stheproponentandtheopponentinanadversarial,dialecticalargument(对话式论证).There’stheaudienceinrhetoricalarguments.There’sthereasonerinargumentsasproofs.Allthesedifferentroles.Now,canyouimagineanargumentinwhichyouarethearguer,butyou’realsointheaudience,watchingyourselfargueCanyouimagineyourselfwatchingyourselfargue(15)Thatmeansyouneedtobesupportedbyyourself.Evenwhenyoulosetheargument,still,attheendoftheargument,youcouldsay,“Wow,thatwasagoodargument!
”CanyoudothatIthinkyoucan.Inthisway,you’vebeensupportedbyyourself.
Uptillnow,Ihavelostalotofarguments.Itreallytakespracticetobecomeagoodarguer,inthesenseofbeingabletobenefitfromlosing,butfortunately,I’vehadmany,manycolleagueswhohavebeenwillingtostepupandprovidethatpracticeforme.
Ok.Tosumup,intoday’slecture,Ihaveintroducedthreemodelsofarguments.
(1)Thefirstmodeliscalledthedialecticalmodel.Thesecondoneisthemodelofargumentsasproofs.(5)Andthelastoneiscalledtherhetoricalmodel,themodelofargumentsasperformances.Ihavealsoemphasizedthat,thoughtheadversarialtypeofargumentsisquitecommon,wecanstillmakeargumentsproducesomepositiveeffects.NexttimeIwillcontinueourdiscussionontheprocessofarguing.