Sex and suicide.docx

Sex and suicide.docx

《Sex and suicide.docx》由会员分享，可在线阅读，更多相关《Sex and suicide.docx（5页珍藏版）》请在冰豆网上搜索。

Sexandsuicide

EDITORIALS

Sexandsuicide

Genderdifferencesinsuicidalbehaviour

KEITHHAWTON,DM

CentreforSuicideResearch,UniversityDepartmentofPsychiatryandWarnefordHospital,Oxford,UK.E-mail:

keith.hawton@psychiatry.ox.ac.uk

Seepp.546-550,thisissue.

Qinetal's（2000,thisissue）epidemiologicalstudyofriskfactorsforsuicideinmalesandfemalesinDenmarkremindsusthatthereareimportantgenderdifferencesinsuicidalbehaviour.Thesereflectnotonlydifferencesinaetiology,whichweretheprimaryfocusoftheDanishstudy,butalsootherimportantvariationsbygenderinrelationtorisk,thenatureofsuicidalbehaviouranditspreventionandtreatment.

RELATIVERISKSOFSUICIDALBEHAVIOUR

Ratesofsuicideinmostcountries,includingDenmark,arehigherinmalesthaninfemales.Chinaisoneimportantexception,withveryhighratesinfemales,especiallyyoungwomeninruralareas（Cheng&Lee,2000）.Inrecentyears,severalcountrieshaveexperiencedanincreaseinsuicideratesinmales,particularlyintheyoungeragegroups（Cantor,2000）.Incontrast,suicideratesoffemaleshavedeclined,especiallyinolderwomen,orremainedfairlystable,particularlyintheyoung.ThispatternisespeciallymarkedintheUK（Hawton,1992）,withanoverallriseinmaleratesandadecreaseinfemalerates（Kelly&Bunting,1998）.Itsuggeststhatcausalfactorsand,possibly,protectivefactorshavechangedindifferentdirectionsinthetwogenders.Socialfactors,especiallylinkedtochangesingenderroles,seemthemostlikelyexplanation（Hawton,1998）.

Incontrasttosuicides,ratesofdeliberateself-harm（DSH）areusuallyhigherinfemalesthanmales.TheWorldHealthOrganization/EUROMulticentreStudyofSuicidalBehaviourhasdemonstratedthispatternthroughoutcountriesinEurope,withfindingsfromHelsinkiindicatingthatFinlandmaybeoneexception（Schmidtkeetal,1996）.Therehas,however,beenanincreaseinratesofDSHinmalesinsomecountries.IntheUKthistrendhasbeenparticularlymarkedinyoungmales（Hawtonetal,1997）.

GENDERDIFFERENCESINTHENATUREOFSUICIDALACTS

TheexcessrateofDSHinfemales,plusthestrongerassociationbetweenDSHandsuicideinmales（Hawton&Fagg,1988;Hawtonetal,1998）,suggestthatactsofDSHbyfemalesaremoreoftenbasedonnon-suicidalmotivation.Infemales,theappealfunctionofDSH,wherebyDSHisusedtocommunicatedistressortomodifythebehaviourandreactionsofotherpeople,seemsmorecommon.Inmales,DSHismoreoftenassociatedwithgreatersuicidalintent.Itisinterestingthatincommunitysamples,suicidalideationisreportedfarmoreoftenbyfemalesthanmales（e.g.Paykeletal,1974）.

ItiswellrecognisedthatmalestendtouseviolentmeansofbothsuicideandDSHmoreoftenthandofemales.Greatersuicidalintent,aggression,knowledgeregardingviolentmeansandlessconcernaboutbodilydisfigurement,arealllikelyexplanationsfortheexcessofviolentsuicideinmales.

AETIOLOGICALFACTORS

AsthefindingsofQinetalindicate,mentalillnessisthepredominantfactorfoundinsuicidesofbothgenders.Theirdatasuggestthatthisisanevengreaterriskinfemales.Astheauthorspointout,however,theirresultsarebasedsolelyonhistoryofinpatientadmissionandthereforewouldhavegreatlyunderestimatedthefullcontributionofpsychiatricdisorders.Theirresultsdonotinformusaboutthenatureofthepsychiatricillnessesfromwhichtheirsuicidessuffered.Psychologicalautopsystudiesclearlydemonstratethataffectivedisorderspredominateinsuicidesofbothgenders,withcomorbidityofpersonalitydisordersin40-50%andothercomorbidpsychiatricdisordersinevenmorecases（e.g.Henrikssonetal,1993;Fosteretal,1997）.Substancemisusedisordersare,however,generallymorecommoninmalesuicides（Murphy,2000）,andindividualswithschizophreniawhokillthemselvesarealsopredominantlymale（DeHert&Peuskens,2000）.Eatingdisorders,especiallyanorexianervosa,carryahighriskofsuicide（Harris&Barraclough,1997）andmostsufferersarefemale.

SOCIO-ECONOMICFACTORSANDMARITALSTATUS

Unemployment,retirement,beingsingleandsicknessabsencewerethesignificantriskfactorsforsuicideintheDanishstudy.Whiledebatecontinuesovertherelativecontributionofunemploymenttosuicidalbehaviour（Platt&Hawton,2000）,theDanishfindingsaddtotheweightofevidencethatoccupationalfactorsareparticularlyimportantinsuicidebymales.Increasedoccupationalinstabilityhasbeenproposedasonefactorbehindtherecentincreaseinyoungmalesuicides,butevidenceisequivocal（Hawton,1998）.

Fartoolittleresearchattentionhasbeenpaidtofactorswhichprotectagainstsuicide.Qinetalidentifiedtheprotectiveroleinfemalesofhavingayoungchild.Thisconfirmspreviousresearchfindingsregardingchildbearing,whichindicatethatpregnancyisalsoatimeofreducedrisk（Appleby,1996）.ItisinterestingthatbeingaparentofayoungchildappearedtoexplaintheapparentprotectiveeffectofmarriageforwomenintheDanishstudyratherthanmarriedstatusperse,whereasinmenmarriageappearedtobeaprotectivefactorinitsownright（orsinglestatusariskfactor）.Furtherpossibleexplanationsproposedfortherecentincreaseinyoungmalesuicideshavebeenthesocialandeconomicchangesthathavemadeitmorefeasibleforfemalestoleaveunsatisfactoryrelationships,whichhasprobablyexposedagreaternumberofvulnerablemalestoriskofsuicidalacts（Hawton,1998）.

TREATMENTANDPREVENTION

Morefemalesthanmalesseekhelpfromgeneralpractitionersformentalhealthproblems.ThisprobablyexplainswhytheapparentbenefitsoftheeducationalprogrammeindetectionandtreatmentofdepressionforgeneralpractitionersontheSwedishislandofGotlandwereconfinedtofemales,moreofwhomweretreatedfordepressionandfewerofwhomcommittedsuicide（Rutzetal,1999）.Whileimproveddetectionandmanagementofpsychiatricdisorderisundoubtedlyakeyfactorinthepreventionofsuicidalbehaviourinmalesaswellasfemales,thereisincreasingevidence,withtheresultsofQinetaladdingtothis,thatalterationsinsocio-economicconditionsarealsoveryrelevanttosuicidepreventioninmales.

Suicidepreventionstrategiesunderstandablyincludeensuringthatcliniciansandotherslikelytoencounterpeopleatriskhaveadequaterisk-assessmentskills.Althoughthepredictivepowerofschedulestoassistriskassessmentisunlikelyevertobesubstantial（Goldney,2000）,thefindingsoftheDanishstudyraisethequestionofwhetherdifferent,ifoverlapping,risk-assessmentschedulesarerequiredforthetwogenders.

Littleresearchattentionhasbeenpaidtopossiblegenderdifferencesinresponsetotreatmentinpeopleatriskofsuicidalacts.Clinicalimpressionsuggeststhatcomplianceofmalepatientsispoorerthanthatoffemales.ThereisalsosomeindicationfromtreatmentstudiesthatfewermalethanfemaleDSHpatientsbenefitfromtreatmentsthattheyareoffered（Hawton,1997）.Whilethismayreflectdifferencesinoverallattitudestohelp,itcouldalsoresultfromthestyleoftherapythatisavailable.Genderdifferencesinverbalabilitiesandthereluctanceofmanymalestoshareemotionalproblemsmaymakesomeoftheusualtalkingtherapieslessattractivetosomemales,atleastinitially.Treatmentprogrammesthathavemoreofapracticalemphasis,perhapsfocusedonproblem-solving,couldprovemoresuccessfulinengagingmalesatrisk.

CONCLUSIONS

Thereareconsiderablegenderdifferencesinsuicidalbehaviour,someofwhichhavebeenhighlightedbytheDanishstudyofQinetal.Theseapplytotheriskofsuicidalbehaviour,anditsnature,causes,preventionandtreatment.Werequirefurtherepidemiologicalstudiesofthiskindtodisentanglemoreofthesocialandeconomicassociationswithsuicidalbehaviourineachgender.Investigationsofgeneticandbiologicalfactorsrelatedtoriskofsuicidalbehaviourareintheirinfancybutshouldbeconductedfromagenderperspective.Researchontreatmentsforsuicidalbehaviourshouldinvestigategenderdifferencesinresponse.Initiativestodevelopgender-specificapproachesmaybeindicated.Genderdifferencesinsuicidalbehaviourclearlymeritmoreresearchattentiontogenerateinformationthatcanguideclinicalpracticeandpreventionstrategiesinwaysthatwillprovemosteffectiveforpreventingsuicidalbehaviourinbothgenders.

REFERENCES

1.Appleby,L.（1996）Suicidalbehaviourinchildbearingwomen.InternationalReviewofPsychiatry,8,107-115.

2.Cantor,C.H.（2000）SuicideintheWesternworld.InTheInternationalHandbookofSuicideandAttemptedSuicide（edsK.Hawton&K.VanHeeringen）,pp.9-28.Chichester:

JohnWiley&Sons.

3.Cheng,A.T.A.&Lee,C.-S.（2000）SuicideinAsiaandtheFarEast.InTheInternationalHandbookofSuicideandAttemptedSuicide（edsK.Hawton&C.VanHeeringen）,pp.121-135.Chichester:

JohnWiley&Sons.

4.DeHert,M.&Peuskens,J.（2000）Psychiatricaspectsofsuicidalbehaviour:

schizophrenia.InTheInternationalHandbookofSuicideandAttemptedSuicide（edsK.Hawton&C.VanHeeringen）.Chichester:

JohnWiley&Sons.

5.Foster,T.,Gillespie,K.&McClelland,R.（1997）MentaldisordersandsuicideinNorthernIreland.BritishJournalofPsychiatry,170,447-452.[Abstract/Free Full Text]

6.Goldney,R.D.（2000）Predictionofsuicideandattemptedsuicide.InTheInternationalHandbookofSuicideandAttemptedSuicide（edsK.Hawton&K.VanHeeringen）,pp.585-596.Chichester:

JohnWiley&Sons.

7.Harris,E.C.&Barraclough,B.（1997）Suicideasanoutcomeformentaldiso