国际会计第七版课后答案第五章 作者弗雷德里克综述.docx
《国际会计第七版课后答案第五章 作者弗雷德里克综述.docx》由会员分享,可在线阅读,更多相关《国际会计第七版课后答案第五章 作者弗雷德里克综述.docx(29页珍藏版)》请在冰豆网上搜索。
国际会计第七版课后答案第五章作者弗雷德里克综述
Chapter5
ReportingandDisclosure
DiscussionQuestions
1.Accountingmeasurementistheprocessofassigningnumericalsymbolstoeventsorobjects.Disclosure,ontheotherhand,isthecommunicationofaccountingmeasurementstointendedusers.Advancesinfinancialdisclosurearelikelytooutpacethoserelatedtoaccountingmeasurementforanumberofreasons.First,manywouldarguethatfinancialdisclosureisalesscontroversialareathanaccountingmeasurement.Second,changesindisclosurerequirementsaremorerapidlyimplementedthanchangesinaccountingmeasurementrules.Finally,whereasasinglesetofaccountingmeasurementrulesmaynotserveusersequallywellunderdifferentsocial,economicandlegalsystems,acompanycandisclosewithoutnecessarilysacrificingitsaccountingmeasurementsystem.
2.Fourreasonswhymultinationalcorporationsareincreasinglybeingheldaccountabletoconstituenciesotherthantraditionalinvestorgroups:
a.Thedevelopmentandgrowthoftheinfluenceoftradeunions.
b.Thegrowingrecognitionoftheviewthatthosewhoaresignificantlyaffectedbydecisionsmadebyinstitutionsingeneralmustbegiventheopportunitytoinfluencethosedecisions.
c.Therejectionbymanygovernmentsofclassicaleconomicpremisessuchasthebeliefthattheregulatedpursuitofprivategainmaximizessociety’swelfare.
d.Theincreasingconcernoverthesocialandeconomicimpactofmultinationalcorporationsinhostcountries.
3.Argumentsinfavorofequaldisclosureinclude:
a.TheabsenceofequaldisclosurewouldcreateanunfairplayingfieldforU.S.companies.Non-U.S.companieswouldhaveacompetitiveadvantageinthattheywouldnothavetodisclosethesameinformationandsowouldnotincurthecostsinvolvedingeneratingandpublishingit.
b.Investorsinnon-U.S.companieshavethesameinformationneedsasthosewhoinvestinU.S.companies.Amarketconcernedwithinvestorprotectionwouldmakesurethatinvestorshavetimelyandmaterialinformationonalllistedcompanies,notjustthosedomiciledintheUnitedStates.
c.Unequaldisclosuremightimpedecross-companycomparisonsinvolvingU.S.andnon-U.S.companies.
Possiblereasonsagainstequaldisclosureinclude:
a.ThehighcostofmeetingequaldisclosurerequirementsmaydeterforeignissuersfromlistingintheUnitedStates.
b.Theextracostsinvolvedworkagainstthebenefitsoflistingtotheforeigncompanies.
Evaluationofarguments:
Alloftheseargumentshavemerit.Thereisnounambiguouslycorrectanswerastowhatdisclosurerequirementsshouldbeimposedonforeignissuers,andtherehasbeenacontentiousdebateonthissubjectintheU.S.inrecentyears.Inpractice,fairnessargumentsoftencarrygreatweightinpublicdebate,evenwhenobjectiveeconomicanalysisdoesnotsupportthem.
4.ManagersinContinentalEuropeandinJapanhaveformanyyearsstronglyobjectedtodisclosinginformationaboutbusinesssegmentfinancialresults.Thesemanagershavearguedthattheinformationcanbeusedbytheircompetitors.Inaddition,ContinentalEuropeandJapanhavehadtraditionsoflowdisclosure.
RequirementsfordisclosureaboutsegmentresultshavebecomemorestringentinJapan,France,andGermanyinresponsetostronginvestorandanalystdemandfortheinformation.Moregenerally,thethreecountriesarestrivingtoimprovethequalityoftheirfinancialreportingstandardsinordertoimprovethereputationandcredibilityoftheircapitalmarkets.
5.Thesimpleansweristhatmandatorydisclosuresarecorporatedisclosuresmadeinresponsetoregulatoryrequirements(forexample,rulesissuedbynationalregulatorsorstockexchanges),andthatvoluntarydisclosuresarepurelydiscretionaryinnature.Thedistinctionbetweenmandatoryandvoluntarydisclosurescanbeambiguousinsomesettings,however.Forexample,therequirementthatU.S.companiesmustfileForm10-KswiththeU.S.SecuritiesandExchangeCommissionisstraightforward.However,measurementanddisclosureapproachesforsomeoftheitemsintheForm10-Karenot.Similarly,therearewidelydivergentviewsconcerningwhattypesofpressannouncementsaremandatoryversusvoluntary.
Twopossibleexplanationsfordifferencesinmanagers’voluntarydisclosurepracticesare:
(1)Managersinhighlycompetitiveindustriesmaybelessforthcomingthanmanagersinlesscompetitiveindustriesduetotheexpectedcostofreleasinginformationofpotentialusetotheircompetitors.
(2)Managersareexpectedtobemoreforthcomingwhenthereisgoodnewstodisclose,thanwhenthereisbadnews,particularlywhenthenewscanbeexpectedtoaffectshareprices.
Twoexplanationsfordifferencesinmanagers’mandatorydisclosurepracticesare:
(1)Cross-jurisdictionaldifferencesindisclosurerequirements.
(2)Differencesintheextentofcompliancewithdisclosurerulesduetocross-jurisdictionaldifferencesinenforcement.
6.Triplebottomlinereportingreferstoreportingonacompany’seconomic,social,andenvironmentalperformance.Itisaformofsocialresponsibilityreportingdesignedtodemonstrategoodcorporatecitizenship.So-called“sustainability”reportsareanincreasinglypopularmeansoftriplebottomlinereporting.Thereissubstantialvariationinsocialreportingtoday.Moreregulationwouldimprovecomparability,butitmightalsostiflereportinginnovations.Theusefulnessofsocialreportingtooutsideparties,particularlyinvestors,needstobedemonstratedbeforeimplementingmoreregulationforit.
6.Oftenweexpecttoobservelessvoluntarydisclosurebycompaniesinemergingmarketcountriesthanbythoseindevelopedcountries:
a.Equitymarketsarerelativelylessdevelopedinmanyemergingmarketcountries,resultinginlowertotaldemandforcompanyinformationbyinvestorsandanalysts.
b.Inmanyemergingmarketcountries,mostfinancingissuppliedbybanksandinsiderssuchasfamilygroups.Thisalsoleadstolessdemandfortimely,crediblepublicdisclosure,andinthesemarketsenhanceddisclosuremayhavelimitedbenefits.
8.Ingeneral,forthesamereasonsasinDiscussionQuestion7,weexpecttoobservefewerregulatorydisclosurerequirementsinemergingmarketcountriesthanindevelopedcountries.Theequitymarketsanddisclosurerequirementsinmanyemergingmarketcountriesarenotyetwelldeveloped,andaccountingandauditingsystemsinemergingmarketcountriesarelesswelldevelopedthaninmoredevelopedmarketcountries.
9.Thetwobroadobjectivesofinvestor-orientedequitymarketsareinvestorprotectionandmarketquality.Intheabsenceofinvestorprotection,investorswillnotbewillingtoparticipateinamarket.However,intheabsenceofmarketquality,marketswillnotfunctionsatisfactorily.Manywouldconsidertheobjectivesequallyimportant.
10.Itcertainlyispossiblethatmorerequireddisclosurewillfurtherencourageinvestorparticipationincapitalmarketsbyprovidingmoreandbetterinformationonwhichtobaseinvestmentdecisions.Benefitsofincreasedinvestorparticipationincludeincreasedliquidity,reducedtransactioncosts,andmoreaccurateandefficientmarketpricing.However,itcanalsobearguedthatinsomesituationsdisclosurerequirementsareexcessive.Inmarketswheredisclosurerequirementsareconsideredtoostringent,companiesmaybedeterredfrompubliclylistingtheirshares,andmaychoosetousesecondarymarkets(suchastheover-the-countermarketintheUnitedStates)thatlacktheinvestorprotectionsofregulatedstockexchanges,andwhichprovideinvestorswithlowerliquidityandhighertransactioncosts.Thus,morerequireddisclosureisnotnecessarilybetterthanless.
11.Forecastsofrevenuesandincomearerelativelyuncommonbecausetherecanbelegalrepercussionsifforecastsarenotmet.Forecastsrelyonsubjectiveestimatesofuncertainfutureevents,makingthemunreliableinmanysituations.Vaguerformsofforwardlookinginformationaremorecommonthanpreciseforecasts.Forexample,directionalforecasts(upordown)ofrevenuesandincomearemorecommonthanrangeforecastswhichare,inturn,morecommonthanpreciseforecastsoftheseamounts.
12.Corporategovernancereferstothestructureofrelationshipsandresponsibilitiesamongshareholders,boardmembers,andcorporatemanagers.Investorsandfinancialanalystsuseinformationaboutacompany’scorporategovernance(forexample,whetheranauditcommittee’smembersareindependent,andresponsibilitiesandremunerationofboardmembers)tobetterassessthelevelofinvestorprotection(andtherefore,expectedcashflowstoinvestors)atthecompany.
Exercises
1.a.Transparentfinancialreportingmeansthattimelyandaccuratedisclosuresaremadeonallimportantmattersaffectingacompany’sfinancialpositionandperformance.Itimpliesopenness,communication,andaccountability.
b.Transparentfinancialreportingprotectsinvestorsbecausenothingishiddenfromthem.Investorscanbetterassesstherisksofowningsecuritieswheninformationistruthfulandcomplete.Transparentfinancialreportingalsoimprovesmarketquality.Itenhancesinvestorconfidence.Opencommunicationcreatesmarketsthatarefair,orderly,efficient,andfreefromabuseandmisconduct.
c.ThefinancialreportingrequirementsontheHongKongExchangepromotetransparentfinancialreportingandtheyprotectinvestorsandpromotemarketquality.Forexample,theyrequireacompletesetofauditedfinancialstatements,includingabalancesheet,incomestatement,cashflowstatement,andexplanatorynotes.Substantialdisclosuresarealsorequired,includingsegmentsandforwardlookinginformationdiscussedinthe