from hope to audacity.docx
《from hope to audacity.docx》由会员分享,可在线阅读,更多相关《from hope to audacity.docx(14页珍藏版)》请在冰豆网上搜索。
![from hope to audacity.docx](https://file1.bdocx.com/fileroot1/2023-2/25/3eac4b5d-afca-4629-b888-2b5179552616/3eac4b5d-afca-4629-b888-2b51795526161.gif)
fromhopetoaudacity
FromHopetoAudacity
TheforeignpolicyofU.S.PresidentBarackObamacanbeassessedmostusefullyintwoparts:
first,hisgoalsanddecision-makingsystemand,second,hispoliciesandtheirimplementation.Althoughonecanspeakwithsomeconfidenceabouttheformer,thelatterisstillanunfoldingprocess.
Tohiscredit,ObamahasundertakenatrulyambitiousefforttoredefinetheUnitedStates'viewoftheworldandtoreconnecttheUnitedStateswiththeemerginghistoricalcontextofthetwenty-firstcentury.Hehasdonethisremarkablywell.Inlessthanayear,hehascomprehensivelyreconceptualizedU.S.foreignpolicywithrespecttoseveralcentrallyimportantgeopoliticalissues:
•Islamisnotanenemy,andthe"globalwaronterror"doesnotdefinetheUnitedStates'currentroleintheworld;
•theUnitedStateswillbeafair-mindedandassertivemediatorwhenitcomestoattaininglastingpeacebetweenIsraelandPalestine;
•theUnitedStatesoughttopursueseriousnegotiationswithIranoveritsnuclearprogram,aswellasotherissues;
•thecounterinsurgencycampaignintheTaliban-controlledpartsofAfghanistanshouldbepartofalargerpoliticalundertaking,ratherthanapredominantlymilitaryone;
•theUnitedStatesshouldrespectLatinAmerica'sculturalandhistoricalsensitivitiesandexpanditscontactswithCuba;
•theUnitedStatesoughttoenergizeitscommitmenttosignificantlyreducingitsnucleararsenalandembracetheeventualgoalofaworldfreeofnuclearweapons;
•incopingwithglobalproblems,Chinashouldbetreatednotonlyasaneconomicpartnerbutalsoasageopoliticalone;
•improvingU.S.-Russianrelationsisintheobviousinterestofbothsides,althoughthismustbedoneinamannerthataccepts,ratherthanseekstoundo,post-ColdWargeopoliticalrealities;and
•atrulycollegialtransatlanticpartnershipshouldbegivendeepermeaning,particularlyinordertohealtheriftscausedbythedestructivecontroversiesofthepastfewyears.
Forallthat,hediddeservetheNobelPeacePrize.Overall,Obamahasdemonstratedagenuinesenseofstrategicdirection,asolidgraspofwhattoday'sworldisallabout,andanunderstandingofwhattheUnitedStatesoughttobedoinginit.Whethertheseconvictionsareabyproductofhispersonalhistory,hisstudies,orhisintuitivesenseofhistory,theyrepresentastrategicallyandhistoricallycoherentworldview.Thenewpresident,itshouldbeadded,hasalsobeenaddressingtheglaringsocialandenvironmentaldilemmasthatconfronthumanityandaboutwhichtheUnitedStateshasbeenindifferentfortoolong.Butthisappraisalfocusesonhisresponsestothemosturgentgeopoliticalchallenges.
CHALLENGESTOWHITEHOUSELEADERSHIP
Obamahasshownagenuinesenseofstrategicdirectionandasolidgraspofwhattoday’sworldisallabout.Obama'soverallperspectivesetsthetoneforhisforeign-policy-makingteam,whichisfirmlycenteredintheWhiteHouse.ThepresidentreliesonVicePresidentJoeBiden'sbroadexperienceinforeignaffairstoexploreideasandengageininformalstrategizing.NationalSecurityAdviserJamesJonescoordinatesthetranslationofthepresident'sstrategicoutlookintopolicy,whilealsohavingtomanagethelargestNationalSecurityCouncilinhistory--itsover-200-personstaffisalmostfourtimesaslargeastheNSCstaffsofRichardNixon,JimmyCarter,andGeorgeH.W.BushandalmosttentimesaslargeasJohnF.Kennedy's.TheinfluenceofSecretaryofDefenseRobertGatesonnationalsecuritystrategyhasbeengrowingsteadily.Gates'immediatetaskistosuccessfullyconcludetwowars,buthisinfluenceisalsofeltonmatterspertainingtoIranandRussia.SecretaryofStateHillaryClinton,whohasthepresident'searaswellashisconfidence,islikewiseakeyparticipantinforeignpolicydecisionsandisthecountry'stopdiplomat.Herownengagementisfocusedmoreontheincreasinglyurgentglobalissuesofthenewcentury,ratherthanonthegeopoliticalonesoftherecentpast.
Finally,Obama'stwotrustedpoliticaladvisers,DavidAxelrodandRahmEmanuel,whocloselymonitorthesensitiverelationshipbetweenforeignanddomesticpolitics,alsoparticipateindecision-making.(Forexample,bothsatinonthepresident'scriticalSeptembermeetingwithIsraeliPrimeMinisterBenjaminNetanyahu.)Whenappropriate,policydiscussionsalsoincludetwoexperiencednegotiators,GeorgeMitchell,whoconductstheMiddleEastpeacenegotiations,andRichardHolbrooke,whocoordinatestheregionalresponsetothechallengesinAfghanistanandPakistan.Ineffect,theyareanextensionofthepresident'sNSC-centeredprocess.
Onthisteam,Obamahimselfisthemainsourceofthestrategicdirection,but,unavoidably,heisabletoplaythisroleononlyapart-timebasis.Thisisaweakness,becausetheconceptualinitiatorofagreatpower'sforeignpolicyneedstobeactivelyinvolvedinsupervisingthedesignoftheconsequentstrategicdecisions,inoverlookingtheirimplementation,andinmakingtimelyadjustments.YetObamahashadnochoicebuttospendmuchofhisfirstyearinofficeondomesticpoliticalaffairs.
Asaresult,hisgrandredefinitionofU.S.foreignpolicyisvulnerabletodilutionordelaybyupper-levelofficialswhohavethebureaucraticpredispositiontofavorcautionoveractionandthefamiliarovertheinnovative.Someofthemmayevenbeunsympathetictothepresident'sprioritiesregardingtheMiddleEastandIran.Ithardlyneedstobeaddedthatofficialswhoarenotinsympathywithadvocatedpoliciesrarelymakegoodexecutors.Additionally,thepresident'sdomesticpoliticaladvisersinevitablytendtobemoresensitivetopressuresfromdomesticinterestgroups.Thisusuallyfostersareluctancetoplanforafirmfollow-throughonboldpresidentialinitiativesshouldtheysuddenlyencounteraforeignrebuffreinforcedbypowerfuldomesticlobbies.Netanyahu'srejectionofObama'spublicdemandthatIsraelhalttheconstructionofsettlementsontheWestBankandinEastJerusalemisacaseinpoint.
Itisstilltooearlytomakeafirmassessmentofthepresident'sdeterminationtopursuehispriorities,asmostofthelargeissuesthatObamahaspersonallyaddressedinvolvelong-rangeproblemsthatcallforlong-termmanagement.Butthreeurgentissuesdopose,evenintheshortrun,animmediateanddifficulttestofhisabilityandhisresolvetosignificantlychangeU.S.policy:
theIsraeli-Palestinianconflict,Iran'snuclearambitions,andtheAfghan-Pakistanichallenge.Eachofthesealsohappenstobeasensitiveissueathome.
THEISRAELI-PALESTINIANCONUNDRUM
Thefirsturgentchallengeis,ofcourse,theMiddleEastpeaceprocess.Obamastatedearlyonthathewouldtaketheinitiativeonthisissueandaimforasettlementintherelativenearterm.ThatpositionisjustifiedhistoricallyandisinkeepingwiththeUnitedStates'nationalinterest.ParalysisovertheIsraeli-Palestinianconflicthaslastedfartoolong,andleavingitunresolvedhasperniciousconsequencesforthePalestinians,fortheregion,andfortheUnitedStates,anditwilleventuallyharmIsrael.Itisnotfashionabletosaythis,butitisdemonstrablytruethat--deservedlyornot--muchofthecurrenthostilitytowardtheUnitedStatesintheMiddleEastandtheIslamicworldasawholehasbeengeneratedbythebloodshedandsufferingproducedbythisprolongedconflict.OsamabinLaden'sself-servingjustificationsfor9/11areareminderthattheUnitedStatesitselfisalsoavictimoftheIsraeli-Palestinianconundrum.
Bynow,aftermorethan40yearsofIsraelioccupationoftheWestBankand30yearsofpeacenegotiations,itisquiteevidentthatlefttothemselves,neithertheIsraelisnorthePalestinianswillresolvetheconflictontheirown.Therearemanyreasonsforthis,butthebottomlineisthatthePalestiniansaretoodividedandtooweaktomakethecriticaldecisionsnecessarytopushthepeaceprocessforward,andtheIsraelisaretoodividedandtoostrongtodothesame.Asaresult,afirmexternalinitiativedefiningthebasicparametersofafinalsettlementisneededtojump-startseriousnegotiationsbetweenthetwoparties.AndthatcanonlycomefromtheUnitedStates.
ButthenecessaryoutsidestimulushasnotyetbeenforthcominginafashionconsistentwithU.S.interestsandpotential.Inraisingtheissueofthesettlementsinthespringof2009butthenlaterbackingoffwhenrebuffedbytheIsraeligovernment,theadministrationstrengthenedthehard-lineelementsinIsraelandundercutthemoremoderateelementsonthePalestinianside.Then,anopportunityprovidedbytheannualUNGeneralAssemblymeetinginSeptembertoidentifytheUnitedStateswiththeoverwhelmingglobalconsensusaboutthebasicparametersofapeacesettlementwassquandered.Insteadofseizingit,ObamamerelyurgedtheIsraelisandthePalestinianstonegotiateingoodfaith.
Yettheexistingglobalconsensuscouldserveasalaunchingpadforseriousnegotiationsonfourbasicpoints.First,PalestinianrefugeesshouldnotbegrantedtherightofreturntowhatisnowIsrael,becauseIsraelcannotbeexpectedtocommitsuicideforthesakeofpeace.TherefugeeswillhavetoberesettledwithinthePalestinianstate,withcompensationandmaybesomeexpressionofregretfortheirsuffering.ThiswillbeverydifficultforthePalestiniannationalmovementtoswallow,butthereisnoalternative.
TheUnitedStatesisalreadylosingtherenewedconfidenceoftheArabworldthatObamawonwithhisspeechinCairo.Second,Jerusalemhastobeshared,andsharedgenuinely.TheIsraelicapital,ofcourse,wouldbeinWestJerusalem,butEastJerusalemsho