Chapter-6-Listening-and-Flowing.ppt

1、Chapter 6 Listening and Flowing,Good Notes,Of:What the other team is sayingYour own arguments before your turn to speak,Burden of Proof,Those who assert must prove.,BP Note-taking,Judges deductively look to the manner and matter of each of the eight debators.Side notes about POIs asked and taken.,Bu

2、rden of Refutation,Refuting arguments.Otherwise,“silence is admission”.,Abbreviations,Agent of action A of ABecause of b/cBetter BBillion bilContention CCost benefit analysis CBACriteria CritDisadvantage DADollar/money Enforcement enfEvidence evFunding fundIncrease Decrease,Impact impcenter Because

3、Therefore Causing/resulting in Caused by/resulted from Strong point Positive/plus+Negative/minus-Economy ecAcademy acSocial/society socHistory/historical his,Inherency inhGreater than Less than Linear/Link LMillion milNot Not equal Number#Observation OPolicy PQuantity QQeustion?,Should s/Should not

4、s/nSignificance sigSolvency solStatus quo SQThousands KTopicality TUniqueness UVoting issue VIWith w/Without w/oCountry World O,Persons Professor/president/prisoner/police/politician p Father f Mother m Son/student s Child(ren)/citizen c Daughter d Grandpa gp Grandma gm Grandson gs Granddaughter gd

5、Leader l Killer k Gangman/gunman g,Format of Notes,PMDPM,LODLO,GMGW,OMOW,THW Ban Capital Punishment in All Cases for All Crimes,PM:Case:All UN members cease immediately;conver to life sentences1.CP doesnt deter crimeA.No empircal proofB.c/n deter crimes of passion2.Errors irreversibleA.The system is

6、 fallible,LODeterrence?Cannot measure effectErrors:In application,not in CP itself;fix system.Counter-case:Preserve CP for crimes against humanity(CAH)1.Justice demands retributionA.Balance depends on payment of debtB.Provides closure2.Need unambiguous moral stance,DPMCAH?Should prohibit in all case

7、sJustice?Moral authority compromised by killing citizens1.Pratical concerns prevent justiceA.No deterrence:no evidence of successB.Errors rampant,compromised justiceC.Racist application,DLOPratice vs Justice?A.Justice is an ideal;strive even if not perfectB.System can be improved;doesnt prove CP unj

8、ustJusticeA.Need balance&clarityB.CP for CAH=improve the human condition,GMCAH?Will not be deterredJustice?Not only about retribution;healing1.Moral objections to CPA.Killing is killingB.CP dehumanizes the stateC.Complicity in CAHs,OMMoral?Immoral to not provide strongest sanctionJustice?Retribution

9、,closure can be healingCase study:Ratko Mlandic(Serbia)A.Complicity in the massacre at Srebrenica in 1995B.indictment by Int.Crim.Trib.For YugoslaviaC.Mladic still at large,evaded capture and trial,GW1.Nature of justice:need moral authority2.Practical FailingsA.No deterrenceB.Errors and racism3.Mora

10、l FailingsA.Dehumanizing and complicityB.C/N object to what you embrace,OW1.What is justice?A.Balance and closureB.Imperative beyond deterrence2.Can CP be administered fairly?3.Do some crimes warrant death?A.Genearlly:CAH shock the consciousB.Specifically:Mladic,THW Ban Capital Punishment in All Cas

11、es for All Crimes,PM:Case:All UN members cease immediately;conver to life sentences1.CP doesnt deter crimeA.No empircal proofB.c/n deter crimes of passion2.Errors irreversibleA.The system is fallibleDPMCAH?Should prohibit in all casesJustice?Moral authority compromised by killing citizens1.Pratical

12、concerns prevent justiceA.No deterrence;:no evidence of successB.Errors rampant,compromised justiceC.Racist applicationGMCAH?Will not be deterredJustice?Not only about retribution;healing1.Moral objections to CPA.Killing is killingB.CP dehumanizes the stateC.Complicity in CAHsGW1.Nature of justice:n

13、eed moral authority2.Practical FailingsA.No deterrenceB.Errors and racism3.Moral FailingsA.Dehumanizing and complicityB.C/N object to what you embrace,LODeterrence?Cannot measure effectErrors:In application,not in CP itself;fix system.Counter-case:Preserve CP for crimes against humanity(CAH)1.Justic

14、e demands retributionA.Balance depends on payment of debtB.Provides closure2.Need unambiguous moral stanceDLOPratice vs Justice?A.Justice is an ideal;strive even if not perfectB.System can be improved;doesnt prove CP unjustJusticeA.Need balance&clarityB.CP for CAH=improve the human conditionOMMoral?

15、Immoral to not provide strongest sanctionJustice?Retribution,closure can be healingCase study:Ratko Mlandic(Serbia)A.Complicity in the massacre at Srebrenica in 1995B.indictment by Int.Crim.Trib.For YugoslaviaC.Mladic still at large,evaded capture and trialOW1.What is justice?A.Balance and closureB.

16、Imperative beyond deterrence2.Can CP be administered fairly?3.Do some crimes warrant death?A.Genearlly:CAH shock the consciousB.Specifically:Mladic,THW Ban Capital Punishment in All Cases for All Crimes,PM:Case:All UN members cease immediately;conver to life sentences1.CP doesnt deter crimeA.No empircal proofB.c/n deter crimes of passion2.Errors irreversibleA.The system is fallibleDPMCAH?Should prohibit in all casesJustice?Moral authority compromised by killing citizens1.Pratical concerns preven