某企业招聘中存在的问题及其规避外文翻译.docx

某企业招聘中存在的问题及其规避外文翻译.docx

《某企业招聘中存在的问题及其规避外文翻译.docx》由会员分享，可在线阅读，更多相关《某企业招聘中存在的问题及其规避外文翻译.docx（7页珍藏版）》请在冰豆网上搜索。

某企业招聘中存在的问题及其规避外文翻译

原文：

Recruitmentinsmallfirms——processes,methodsandproblem

MarilynCarroll

AbstractThearticlesummarisesfindingsfromrecentcasestudyresearchintorecruitmentinsmallfirms.Theresearchaimstoascertainwhethersmallfirmsfollowtheproceduresoutlinedintheprescriptiveliteratureonrecruitment,andtowhatextenttheyrelyoninformalrecruitmentmethods.Itfindslittleevidenceoftheadoptionoftherecommendedsystematicproceduresandahighuseof“triedandtrusted”methodsincludingword-of-mouthrecruitmentandthehiringof“knownquantities”.Theimplicationsofthisareexamined.Whilethesemethodshavecertainadvantages,theymayalsogiverisetoanumberofproblems.Thestudyarguesthattheadoptionofmoreformalproceduresandmethodscouldreducestaffturnoverinsmallfirmsanditsassociatedcosts.However,itconcludesthatmanysmallemployerswouldremainunconvincedbythecaseforopeninguprecruitmentchannels,andmayfindtheirexistingapproachesmorecosteffectiveintheshortterm.

Introduction

Aconsiderablequantityofprescriptiveliteratureisavailabletomanagersresponsibleforrecruitingstaffaimedathelpingthemtoincreasethechancesoffindingtherightpersonforthejob.Mostofthisadvice,however,seemstobeaimedatlargeorganisations.Assumptionsaremadeaboutthedegreeofformalitywhichwouldnormallycharacterisetherecruitmentprocessandtheextenttowhichemployersarelikelytoadoptsystematicandproactivesearchesfornewrecruits.Incontrast,relativelylittlematerialisavailablespecificallyforsmallfirms.AsHendry etal. （1995,p.14）note,“trainingandhumanresourcemanagementadvicetosmallerfirmshasbeenmonotonousinitsprescriptionoflarge-scalesolutions”.

Recruitmentinthecasestudyfirms

Althoughsomefirmsmightbeconsideredtobetoosmalltoofferopportunitiesforcareerprogressionormovementintoadifferenttypeofwork,therewasagreatdealofevidenceoftheoperationofinternallabourmarkets.Reasonsgivenbytherespondentswere“tomotivatepeople”,“toencourageloyaltytothefirm”,“betterthedevilyouknow”,orbecausealowerlevelvacancywouldbeeasiertofillexternally.Inthehotelandcateringsectorandsolicitorsfirmstherewasmostscopeforinternalpromotion.Hotelsandcateringsectormanagerstriedtoidentifypeoplewithaptitudeandabilityandpromotethemintoamoreseniororsupervisoryrolewhenavacancyarose.Thosesolicitors’firmswhichtooktraineessaidtheylikedtokeepthemonifpossibleaftertheyqualifiedandthereisarecognisedcareerpathtoassociate,salariedpartnerandequitypartner.Intheprintingandroadhaulagesectorstherewereveryfewopportunitiesforpromotionbecauseofthenatureofthework.However,printerssometimeshadtheopportunitytomoveontooperatingabiggermachineanddriverstoalargervehicle.Thenursinghomes,however,founditmostdifficulttoofferopportunitiesforcareerprogressionbecause,foracareassistant,thiswouldmeanleavingtoundertakeformalnursetraining.

Closedsearcheswereamongthemostwidelyusedrecruitmentmethodsinthecasestudyfirms.Allhadusedrecommendationsfromstaff,27percenthadfoundstaffthroughanetworkofcontactsintheindustryand13percenthadpoachedstaffdirectlyfromcompetitors.Oneprintingcompanyhadbeenabletofillallitsvacanciesbythesemethodssincestartingsixyearsago.Employingfriendsandfamilymembersofexistingstaffwasespeciallycommoninthehotelsandcatering,roadhaulageandnursinghomesectors.Theviewwasexpressedthatpeoplerecruitedinthiswayweremorelikelyto“blendin”well.Inthehotelsandcateringsector,especiallyforjobswhichinvolvecash-handling,someknowledgeofthebackgroundofthepotentialrecruitwasthoughtessential.However,afewemployersexpressedreservationsaboutemployingfriendsandfamilymembersbecause“ifyoufalloutwithoneyoulosetwo”.Forsolicitorstherecruitmentoffee-earners“throughthenetwork”waswidespreadincludingofferingemploymenttosolicitorswhohadworkedfor“theotherside”inacase.Thefirmshadampleopportunitiestoassessthecapabilitiesofpotentialrecruits,byobservinghowtheyperformedincourt,forexample.Attitudestowardspoachingstaffvaried.Whilesomeintervieweeswouldpoachstaffwithoutanyreservations,othersregardedthepracticeas“unethical”.AsthemanagerofanIndianrestaurantputit,“ithappensveryoftenroundherebutIdon’tdoittootherpeoplebecauseIdon’tlikeithappeningtome”.Sometimescompetentstaffwere“poachedback”afterleavingtoworkforanotheremployerand,indeed,thehiringofformeremployeeswascommon,especiallyintheroadhaulageindustry,wheredriversoftenmovedaroundfromonecompanytoanother.Inallsectors,apartfromroadhaulagewheredrivershavetobeatleast21totrain,somefirmsrecruiteddirectfromlocaleducationalestablishments.Typicalreasonsforusingclosedsearchesincludedthebeliefthatanexistingmemberofstaffisunlikelytorecommendsomeoneunsuitable,thepreferencefora“knownquantity”,andvaluingsomeonewhowould“fitin”.Onlytwooftheinterviewees（solicitors）expressedreservationsaboutinformal,wordofmouthrecruitmentbecauseoftheequalopportunitiesimplications,andbecauseitwasthoughtpreferabletoconsider“thewholefield”.

Responsiverecruitmentmethodswerealsowidelyused.Overhalflookedatformerapplicationsagainifasimilarvacancyarose.Similarly,overhalfwouldofferworktocasualcallerswhocontactedthefirmeitherbytelephoneorinperson,providedtherewasavacancyandthepersonwassuitable;70percentkeptaregisterofinterestedapplicantsorafileofCVs.Tosomeextent,thisapproachisratherlessproactivethantheothers,relyingonapoolofpotentialrecruitswhohadhappenedtocontactthefirm.Ontheotherhand,itcouldbearguedthattheseindividualsutilisedtheirinitiativeinseekingwork,andmightbeallthemoreattractivetoemployersbecauseofthis.

Ofthemoreformal“opensearch”recruitmentmethods,advertisinginJobcentresandthelocalpresswerethemostcommon.Jobcentreswereroutinelyusedbyalmostallthecasestudyfirms,atleastforsomecategoriesofstaff.TheadvantagesofJobcentresweresaidtobethattheyarefree,andtheadvertisementstaysinuntilthevacancyisfilled.However,whilesomeintervieweesfoundtheJobcentrestobeagoodsourceofnewrecruits,othersexpresseddissatisfactionwiththestandardofserviceoffered.Themostfrequentcomplaintswerethatcandidateswere“notproperlyvetted”,theyfrequentlyfailedtoturnupforinterview,ortheywere“notreallyinterestedinfindingajob”.Fewerfirmsusedotherrecruitmentagencies,mainlybecausetheywereregardedasexpensive.Specialistdriveragencieswerecriticisedbytheroadhaulagecompanies,withonlytwohavingusedthem,andthenmerelyasalastresort.Onceagain,thepeopleontheirbookswerethoughttobe“notproperlyvetted”,inexperienced,ornotlookingforpermanent,full-timework.Althoughmostfirmshadadvertisedinthelocalpress,someonlydidsowhenlessexpensivemethodshadfailedtoproduceasuitablecandidate.Thewholeprocessofadvertising,aninitialtelephonescreening（sometimes）,siftingthroughCVsorapplicationforms,shortlisting,interviewing,checkingreferences（possibly）andmakingaselectiondecisionwasthoughttobenotonlycostlyintermsofmanagementtime,butwasregardedasa“hitandmissaffair”.Onlythreefirmshadadvertisedinthenationalpress,andineachcasethiswasa“one-off”tofillamanagementpositionratherthanbeingusedasaregularrecruitmentmethod.Specialistjournalswere,however,morewidelyused,especiallybythesolicitors’firms.Anotheropensearchmethodpopularwiththebarsandpubswasplacinganoticeofthevacancyinthebaritself,whichwasfelthadtheadvantageofattractingthesametypeofpersonastheestablishment’scustomers.Otheropensearchmethodsofrecruitmentusedbythenursinghomeswereplacingnoticesofvacanciesinpostofficesandnewsagentsand,inonecase,advertisingonlocalradio.

Havingreviewedtheextenttowhichthesefirmsfollowedprescriptionsabouttherecruitmentprocessandthemethodstheyusedtoattractstaff,wecannowturntoanassessmentoftheproblemsencounteredinrecruitment.Despiteusingavarietyofmethods,severalofthecasestudyorganisationsreporteddifficultiesattractingstaff.Insomecasesthesedifficultieswerecompoundedbyhighstaffturnoverratessothat,despitetheirsmallsize,thefirmshadongoingrecruitmentdrives,involvingpermanentadvertisementsintheJobcentreand/orregularadvertisementsinthelocalpress.

Noneoftheemployershadactuallycalculatedthedirectandindirectcostsofrecruitmentand,indeed,somesaidtheywouldrathernotknow.Typicalresponseswere“it’sanecessaryevil”and“Idon’tneedanythingelsetohorrifyme”.Althoughseveraloftheemployersadmittedtohavingmadeexpensivemistakes,generallyhighlevelsofsatisfactionwithrecruitmentmethodswereexpressed.Mostemployersusedarangeofdifferentmethodsandmanysaid“Idon’tknowhowelsewe’ddoit”.Wheretherewereproblems,theywerethoughttostemfromashortageofsuitablecandidates,ratherthanrecruitmentmethodsassuch.

Conclusions

Themainpurposeofthispaperhasbeentooutlineandanalysethewaysinwhichrecruitmenttakesplaceinsmallfirms,drawingondatacollectedduring1998fromasampleof40organisationsintheNorthWestofEngland.Theprojectfocusedonfivediverseindustries（hotelsandcatering,roadhau