旅游和社会经济发展肯尼亚蒙巴萨旅游度假区的案例研究外文翻译Word格式.docx
《旅游和社会经济发展肯尼亚蒙巴萨旅游度假区的案例研究外文翻译Word格式.docx》由会员分享,可在线阅读,更多相关《旅游和社会经济发展肯尼亚蒙巴萨旅游度假区的案例研究外文翻译Word格式.docx(24页珍藏版)》请在冰豆网上搜索。
DepartmentofTourismManagement,MoiUniversity,Eldoret,Kenya
Author:
JohnS.AkamaandDamiannahKieti
ThispaperlooksatissuessurroundingsustainabletourismasatoolforlocalsocioeconomicdevelopmentinKenya,usingthecasestudyofMombasaResortTown.IllustratedbyprimarydatafromfieldinterviewsandsurveysinMombasa,backedbysecondarydata,itfindsthatduetothenatureoftheKenyantourismindustry(externalcontrolandmanagementoftourismestablishments,limitedlocalinvolvementandhighleakagerates),theindustryhasnotplayedaneffectiveroleinlocalsocio-economicdevelopment.Waysforwardaresuggested.doi:
10.2167/jost543.0
Keywords:
tourismindevelopingcountries,sustainabletourismdevelopment,
socio-economicdevelopment,Kenyantourism,communitytourism
Introduction
Theconceptofsustainabletourismstrivestoharmoniseandreconcileissuesofintergenerationalequity,andthegoalsofeconomicgrowth,environmentalprotectionandsocialjustice.Itrecognisestheneedforfairnessbetweenlocalindividualsandgroups,andbetweenhostsandguests(Mbaiwa,2005).Iftheconceptofsustainabletourismistransformedintoaction,itisexpectedtocontributetothesustainabilityoftheenvironment,socialandculturalresourcesandoverallsocio-economicdevelopment.Theincreasingpopularityoftheconceptderivesfromthewidelyheldviewthatthereisaneedtoaltercurrentformsofconsumptionthatperceiveexistingresourcesasbeinginfinite.
Alotofattentionhasbeenpaidtotheeconomicandecologicalaspectsofsustainabledevelopment,especiallyatthenationallevel(Roe&
Khanya,2001;
Scheyvens,2002),butlittlehasbeengiventotheanalysisoftheimplicationsofsustainabletourismonspecificlocalcommunitiesandontheindustry’simpactonthequalityoflifeandonsocio-ecologicalaspectsofcommunitiesthataredirectlyaffectedbythetourismindustry,particularlyindevelopingcountries
suchasKenya.Thispaperaddressesthoseissues.TourismdevelopmentinKenyaKenyaprovidesagoodexampleofadevelopingcountrythathasembracedtourismasatoolforsocio-economicdevelopment.KenyahasincreasinglybecomeapopulartouristdestinationforvisitorsfromEurope,NorthAmericaandemergingtourist-generatingregions,particularlySouth-eastAsia(Table1).Thecountryreceivesover6%ofthetotalinternationaltouristarrivalstoAfrica,andtherelativeimportanceoftourisminKenya’seconomyhasrisensteadilyoverthelast40years(KenyaGovernment,2004).However,tobeofanymeaningtomarginalisedlocalcommunitiesandindividuals,especiallyindevelopingcountriessuchasKenya,tourismdevelopmentshouldbepartofabroaderalternativepolicyframeworkthatisdesignedtoachieveasustainablesociety.Sustainabletourismdevelopmentshould,therefore,notbeseenasanendinitself,butasoneoftheseveralalternativedevelopmentstrategiesthatcanassistlocalcommunitiesovercometheirsocio-economicanddevelopmentalweaknesses,preservetheirstrengthsandenhancetheirdevelopmentalopportunities.Table1Departingvisitorsbycountryofresidenceandpurposeofvisit,2000–2001(‘000)
CountryofResidenceHolidayBusinessTransitTotal
20002001200020012000200120002001
Germany187.0179.74.44.224.719.0206.1202.9
UnitedKingdom119.9115.217.316.611.014.3148.2146.1
Switzerland19.919.12.62.53.44.425.926.0
Italy24.623.62.92.82.83.630.330.1
France18.918.22.72.63.14.024.724.8
Scandinavia16.115.52.22.12.73.521.021.1
OtherEurope147.6141.83.33.215.420.0166.5165.0
TotalEurope534.0513.135.434.053.168.8622.5615.9
USA44.743.05.14.94.35.654.053.4
Canada14.213.61.91.82.22.918.318.3
TotalNorthAmerica58.956.67.06.76.58.472.371.7
Uganda14.313.721.220.44.45.739.939.8
Tanzania25.224.25.75.511.715.242.644.9
OtherAfrica30.829.617.516.814.318.562.664.9
TotalAfrica70.367.644.442.730.439.4145.1149.6
India12.111.62.42.32.33.016.716.6
Japan10.4101.21.21.11.412.812.6
Israel5.95.70.80.80.40.57.27.0
OtherAsia12.712.23.33.23.03.929.219.3
TotalAsia41.139.57.77.46.88.855.655.7
Australiaand
NewZealand
13.913.41.71.61.82.317.317.3
Allothercountries5451.90.80.84.96.359.759.0
Total772.2742.097.093.2103.5134.1972.7969.3
MombasaistheleadingtouristcentreinEasternAfrica,withthehighestconcentrationoftourismandhospitalityfacilitiesandinfrastructure.MombasaandadjacenttownshipsreceiveoveronethirdofinternationaltouristarrivalstoKenya.However,Mombasainparticular,andtheKenyancoastalregioningeneral,isclassifiedbythegovernmentasoneoftheregionswithahighincidenceofpovertyandpoorlivingconditionsforlocalpeople(KenyaGovernment,2004).Ithasbeenestimatedthatover50%oftheresidentsofMombasalivebelowthepovertyline,earninglessthanUS$1perday.IntheKenyancontext,thepovertylineisthelevelatwhichanindividual’sincomedoesnotmeet‘aminimumstandardrequiredtomeethisorherbasicneedssuchasfood,shelter,sanitationandcleanwatersupply’(KenyaGovernment,2004:
195).OverhalfofMombasa’s500,000residentscannotaffordadecentmeal,donothaveaccesstocleanwaterorbasicsanitaryfacilitiesandcanneitheraffordbasichealthcarenorpayschoolfeesfortheirchildren.Oftenthepeoplelivingbelowthepovertylinehavenoregularemployment,theirincomeissmallandirregularandtheylackbasiccapitaltostartmicro-scalebusinessenterprisesintourismandothersectors.Quiteoften,thechildrenofpeoplelivingbelowthepovertylinedonotattendschoolandevenwhentheydo,thedropoutrateisquitehigh.Hence,mostofthechildrenrarelygobeyondelementaryschool.Theconsequencesofthisabjectpovertyandsocialdeprivationisreflectedinanincreasedincidenceofinsecurity,theft,drug-takingandtrafficking,prostitution,hungerandmalnutrition,highmortalityrate,highlevelsofilliteracy,anincreasedincidenceofchildlabour,domesticviolenceandfamilybreakups
(KenyaGovernment,1999a,1999b).
Inthisregard,itshouldbeasked,iftourismisamaineconomicsectorinMombasaandothercentresinKenya,whatroleistheindustryplayingintheimprovementofthelivingconditionsofthelocalpeople?
Istourismanappropriatetoolforsustainablelocalsocio-economicdevelopment?
Thisstudyaddressessomeofthecriticalissuesonsustainabletourismdevelopment,particularlyasitrelatestoequitabledistributionofthetourismbenefitstodifferentstakeholders,localparticipationintourismdecisionmakingprocesses,theleakagerateandmultipliereffectsoftourismanditsmarketing.
MethodologyThisresearchusesacasestudyofMombasaandadjacenttownshipstoanalysetheroleplayedbytourismasanoptionforsustainablelocalcommunitydevelopment.ItexaminestouristmotivationsforvisitingMombasa,theirresponsestotheareaandsetsthisstudyagainstlocalresidents’viewsofthetouristindustry.
Thestudypopulationconsistedof:
(1)localpeoplelivinginMombasaandtheadjacentareaand
(2)touristsinthesamearea.Clustersamplingwasappliedtoselectthesamplingunits(i.e.Kisauni,LikoniandChangamwe)wheremostlocalpeoplereside.Conveniencesamplingtechniqueswereappliedtorecruitrespondentsfromeachsamplingunit.Datacollectionwasbyacombinationofquestionnaires,interviewsandfieldobservation.Questionnairesandfieldinterviewswereadministeredinlocationssuchashotelsandrestaurants,entertainmentcentres,attractionsitesandalongthestreetsandresidentialareas.Inaddition,scheduledinterviewsandstructureddialoguewasconductedwithselectedprivateandpublicsectorrepresentatives,localcommunityleadersandpoliticians.
Twotypesofquestionnaireswereadministered–oneforlocalpeopleandtheotherfortourists.Eachquestionnairewasdividedintothreesections.Thefirstsectioncoveredgeneralsociodemographicattributes,whilethesecondsectionaddressedoverallissuesontourismdevelopmentsuchasexistingtouristattractions,formsofinteractionsbetweenresidentsandtourists,andtheuseoflocaltourismresourcesandrecreationalfacilities.Thelastsectionofthequestionnaireprobedtheroleoftourismasatoolforlocalsocio-economicdevelopmentincluding
existingformsoftourismemployment,localdecisionmakingprocesses,ownershipandmanagementoftourismresources,formsoftourismmarketingandthedistributionoftourismrevenuesamongvariousstakeholders.
ThisstudywasundertakenfromJunetoJuly2002.Twohundredandtwentyseveninternationaltouristsandasimilarnumberoflocalresidentswereinterviewed.Thedatacollectedwasorganised,tabulatedandanalysedusingcomputerstatisticalpackages.
ResearchFindingsInternationaltouristsAsummaryoffindingsisgiveninTable2.Eightypercentoftheinternationaltouristsweretravellingunderaninclusivetourpackage.Asisusually
thecharacteristicofall-inclusivetourpackagetravelarrangements,mostinternationaltourists(87%)statedthattheywerestayinginhigh-classresorthotelsandcondominiums(i.e.3-to5-starhotels)foraperiodof7–21days.MostofthesegrandtourismandhospitalityestablishmentsareundertheownershipandmanagementofmultinationalandforeigninvestorsincludingHayesandJavuis,LonhroCorporation,UnitedTourcompanies,Kuoni,AfricaClub,UniversalSafariTours,Pollmans,FrancoRussoandGrandViaggi.
Asignificant53%