Chapter-6-Listening-and-Flowing.ppt
《Chapter-6-Listening-and-Flowing.ppt》由会员分享,可在线阅读,更多相关《Chapter-6-Listening-and-Flowing.ppt(28页珍藏版)》请在冰豆网上搜索。
Chapter6ListeningandFlowing,GoodNotes,Of:
WhattheotherteamissayingYourownargumentsbeforeyourturntospeak,BurdenofProof,Thosewhoassertmustprove.,BPNote-taking,Judgesdeductivelylooktothemannerandmatterofeachoftheeightdebators.SidenotesaboutPOIsaskedandtaken.,BurdenofRefutation,Refutingarguments.Otherwise,“silenceisadmission”.,Abbreviations,AgentofactionAofABecauseofb/cBetterBBillionbilContentionCCostbenefitanalysisCBACriteriaCritDisadvantageDADollar/moneyEnforcementenfEvidenceevFundingfundIncreaseDecrease,ImpactimpcenterBecauseThereforeCausing/resultinginCausedby/resultedfromStrongpointPositive/plus+Negative/minus-EconomyecAcademyacSocial/societysocHistory/historicalhis,InherencyinhGreaterthanLessthanLinear/LinkLMillionmilNotNotequalNumber#ObservationOPolicyPQuantityQQeustion?
Shoulds/Shouldnots/nSignificancesigSolvencysolStatusquoSQThousandsKTopicalityTUniquenessUVotingissueVIWithw/Withoutw/oCountryWorldO,PersonsProfessor/president/prisoner/police/politicianpFatherfMothermSon/studentsChild(ren)/citizencDaughterdGrandpagpGrandmagmGrandsongsGranddaughtergdLeaderlKillerkGangman/gunmang,FormatofNotes,PMDPM,LODLO,GMGW,OMOW,THWBanCapitalPunishmentinAllCasesforAllCrimes,PM:
Case:
AllUNmembersceaseimmediately;convertolifesentences1.CPdoesntdetercrimeA.NoempircalproofB.c/ndetercrimesofpassion2.ErrorsirreversibleA.Thesystemisfallible,LODeterrence?
CannotmeasureeffectErrors:
Inapplication,notinCPitself;fixsystem.Counter-case:
PreserveCPforcrimesagainsthumanity(CAH)1.JusticedemandsretributionA.BalancedependsonpaymentofdebtB.Providesclosure2.Needunambiguousmoralstance,DPMCAH?
ShouldprohibitinallcasesJustice?
Moralauthoritycompromisedbykillingcitizens1.PraticalconcernspreventjusticeA.Nodeterrence:
noevidenceofsuccessB.Errorsrampant,compromisedjusticeC.Racistapplication,DLOPraticevsJustice?
A.Justiceisanideal;striveevenifnotperfectB.Systemcanbeimproved;doesntproveCPunjustJusticeA.Needbalance&clarityB.CPforCAH=improvethehumancondition,GMCAH?
WillnotbedeterredJustice?
Notonlyaboutretribution;healing1.MoralobjectionstoCPA.KillingiskillingB.CPdehumanizesthestateC.ComplicityinCAHs,OMMoral?
ImmoraltonotprovidestrongestsanctionJustice?
Retribution,closurecanbehealingCasestudy:
RatkoMlandic(Serbia)A.ComplicityinthemassacreatSrebrenicain1995B.indictmentbyInt.Crim.Trib.ForYugoslaviaC.Mladicstillatlarge,evadedcaptureandtrial,GW1.Natureofjustice:
needmoralauthority2.PracticalFailingsA.NodeterrenceB.Errorsandracism3.MoralFailingsA.DehumanizingandcomplicityB.C/Nobjecttowhatyouembrace,OW1.Whatisjustice?
A.BalanceandclosureB.Imperativebeyonddeterrence2.CanCPbeadministeredfairly?
3.Dosomecrimeswarrantdeath?
A.Genearlly:
CAHshocktheconsciousB.Specifically:
Mladic,THWBanCapitalPunishmentinAllCasesforAllCrimes,PM:
Case:
AllUNmembersceaseimmediately;convertolifesentences1.CPdoesntdetercrimeA.NoempircalproofB.c/ndetercrimesofpassion2.ErrorsirreversibleA.ThesystemisfallibleDPMCAH?
ShouldprohibitinallcasesJustice?
Moralauthoritycompromisedbykillingcitizens1.PraticalconcernspreventjusticeA.Nodeterrence;:
noevidenceofsuccessB.Errorsrampant,compromisedjusticeC.RacistapplicationGMCAH?
WillnotbedeterredJustice?
Notonlyaboutretribution;healing1.MoralobjectionstoCPA.KillingiskillingB.CPdehumanizesthestateC.ComplicityinCAHsGW1.Natureofjustice:
needmoralauthority2.PracticalFailingsA.NodeterrenceB.Errorsandracism3.MoralFailingsA.DehumanizingandcomplicityB.C/Nobjecttowhatyouembrace,LODeterrence?
CannotmeasureeffectErrors:
Inapplication,notinCPitself;fixsystem.Counter-case:
PreserveCPforcrimesagainsthumanity(CAH)1.JusticedemandsretributionA.BalancedependsonpaymentofdebtB.Providesclosure2.NeedunambiguousmoralstanceDLOPraticevsJustice?
A.Justiceisanideal;striveevenifnotperfectB.Systemcanbeimproved;doesntproveCPunjustJusticeA.Needbalance&clarityB.CPforCAH=improvethehumanconditionOMMoral?
ImmoraltonotprovidestrongestsanctionJustice?
Retribution,closurecanbehealingCasestudy:
RatkoMlandic(Serbia)A.ComplicityinthemassacreatSrebrenicain1995B.indictmentbyInt.Crim.Trib.ForYugoslaviaC.Mladicstillatlarge,evadedcaptureandtrialOW1.Whatisjustice?
A.BalanceandclosureB.Imperativebeyonddeterrence2.CanCPbeadministeredfairly?
3.Dosomecrimeswarrantdeath?
A.Genearlly:
CAHshocktheconsciousB.Specifically:
Mladic,THWBanCapitalPunishmentinAllCasesforAllCrimes,PM:
Case:
AllUNmembersceaseimmediately;convertolifesentences1.CPdoesntdetercrimeA.NoempircalproofB.c/ndetercrimesofpassion2.ErrorsirreversibleA.ThesystemisfallibleDPMCAH?
ShouldprohibitinallcasesJustice?
Moralauthoritycompromisedbykillingcitizens1.Praticalconcernspreven